Carbon Footprint — Operations: How does Toby Carvery score?

Toby Carvery is a brand within Mitchells & Butlers (M&B) plc, which publishes group-level GHG data. The M&B Annual Report 2024 (FY2024, 52 weeks to 28 September 2024) references Scope 1, 2, and 3 targets and TCFD-consistent disclosures, and notes ongoing reductions driven by reduced energy consumption and reduced gas reliance (AR2024 Strategic Report). However, no Toby-Carvery-specific Scope 1 or Scope 2 figures in absolute tonnes CO2e are publicly disclosed at the brand level. M&B group-level a

Carbon Footprint — Supply Chain: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B acknowledges that food sold is 'the largest contributor to our greenhouse gas footprint' (mbcareersandjobs.com) and has an SBTi-validated target to reduce absolute Scope 3 emissions by 28% by FY2030 from a 2019 base. The AR2024 Strategic Report notes TCFD compliance is confirmed 'except for Scope 3 emissions', indicating Scope 3 quantification is incomplete or not publicly disclosed in full. Toby Carvery's core menu is meat-heavy (beef, pork, chicken, turkey), placing it in a high-Scope-3-ri

Emissions Trajectory: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B reported an 11% reduction in total footprint (Scope 1, 2, and 3) in FY2023 (press release, January 2024). The FY2024 AR Strategic Report notes further reduction driven by reduced energy consumption and reduced reliance on gas. The parent company website reports 16% progress towards net zero from the 2019 baseline. The SBTi-validated near-term targets are absolute (not intensity-based): 70% absolute Scope 1 & 2 reduction and 28% absolute Scope 3 reduction by FY2030 vs 2019. This is directiona

Energy Source: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B states it purchases 100% renewable electricity across its estate ('we ensure that all our energy is generated from renewable sources' — Ian Reeley, Head of Sustainability Solar PV Development, quoted in Geo Green Power case study). The 'Respect for the Planet' page confirms purchasing 100% renewable electricity and installing solar panels. By end-2024, 60 solar PV installations were completed (total 1,859 kWp, reducing emissions by 395 tonnes/year). Gas remains in use across the estate and i

Nature & Biodiversity Impact: How does Toby Carvery score?

Toby Carvery's core product is roast meat (beef, pork, chicken, turkey), making agricultural land use and associated biodiversity impact a material concern in its supply chain. M&B states commitment to 'protecting biodiversity' and sources UK meat to Red Tractor standard, which covers some basic environmental practices. However, no TNFD disclosure, no quantified biodiversity footprint, no deforestation-free commitment, and no verified nature strategy is evidenced at either brand or group level i

Resource Use & Waste: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B has measurable progress on waste: as of September 2024, 99% of operational waste diverted from landfill (up from 96% in April 2022), 23% food waste reduction vs 2019 baseline, and 60% of operational waste recycled. Targets include zero operational waste to landfill by 2030 and 50% food waste reduction by 2030. The Too Good To Go partnership across all 153 Toby Carvery sites has saved over 1.2 million Magic Bags and 3,000 tCO2e as of 2024. Printing supply chain uses ISO 14001-certified printe

Water Impact: How does Toby Carvery score?

No water consumption data (in absolute volume), water stewardship programme, or water reduction targets are evidenced at brand or group level in available sources. A 2021 Food Foundation scorecard noted M&B's action point was to 'review water usage and develop strategy to reduce consumption' with 'no information found' on this metric at that time. No evidence that water data has been published since. As a restaurant chain serving over 100 million meals per year (M&B group, FY2024), water use in

Targets & Commitments: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B's net zero roadmap was validated by the SBTi in January 2024. Near-term targets (absolute): reduce Scope 1 & 2 by 70% by FY2030, reduce Scope 3 by 28% by FY2030, both vs a FY2019 baseline. Long-term target (absolute): reduce Scope 1, 2, and 3 by 90% by FY2040, net zero. Additional commitments: zero operational waste to landfill by 2030, 50% food waste reduction by 2030. These are absolute (not intensity-based) targets, validated by SBTi, and cover all three scopes. No significant reliance on

Transparency & Accountability: How does Toby Carvery score?

M&B has a Director of Investor Relations and Sustainability (Amy De Marsac), a Corporate Responsibility Committee with board oversight, and CEO Phil Urban leads climate change policy initiatives. TCFD-consistent disclosures are confirmed in the FY2024 Annual Report, with the exception of full Scope 3 emissions disclosure. The sustainability strategy is publicly documented on the M&B website with targets and progress indicators. However, Toby Carvery as a brand does not publish its own sustainabi

Controversies & Red Flags: How does Toby Carvery score?

Starting score 8. The most significant documented environmental incident is the April 2025 felling of a 500-year-old oak tree ('the Whitewebbs Oak') at a Toby Carvery site in Enfield, North London. A Forestry Commission investigation confirmed the tree was alive when felled without permission; Enfield Council (the land owner) reported the matter to Metropolitan Police as criminal damage and placed a Tree Preservation Order on the remains; legal action by the council is ongoing; the UK junior env

← Back to leaderboard

Toby Carvery Sustainability Score: 40/100

◌ Pending Review

🍖 Food Service / RestaurantsGBBelow expectations

~44,000 (Mitchells & Butlers group; Toby Carvery operates ~153 sites within the estate of ~1,726) employees~£2,610M (Mitchells & Butlers FY2024 group revenue; Toby Carvery is one brand within the group) revenueRanked #217 of 503Website ↗

Toby Carvery is a food service / restaurants company headquartered in GB. Based on our 10-question rubric, Toby Carvery scores 40/100 — rated as below expectations on sustainability for a company of its size and profile.

SINK Score Breakdown

How we calculated Toby Carvery's score using our formula: (0.3 × Base + 0.7 × Performance) × Scale Penalty

Base Impact

Food Service / Restaurants industry ceiling

Performance

41/100

10 questions scored below

Scale Penalty

0.95x

emissions volume multiplier

SINK Score

(0.3 × 45 + 0.7 × 41) × 0.95 = 40

10-Question Rubric Breakdown

Click any question to see the reasoning, sources and community challenges.

4/10

Carbon Footprint — Operations

3/10

Carbon Footprint — Supply Chain

4/10

Emissions Trajectory

6/10

Energy Source

2/10

Nature & Biodiversity Impact

5/10

Resource Use & Waste

2/10

Water Impact

6/10

Targets & Commitments

5/10

Transparency & Accountability

Q10

4/10

Controversies & Red Flags

Community Verification

0 verifications · 0 challenges · Scored using SINK editorial review

Last scored: 9 Apr 2026

Think this score is wrong?

Challenge any question above with evidence. All challenges are published publicly.

Read methodology →

More in Food Service / Restaurants

50Wahaca 49J D Wetherspoon 48Harvester 47ASK Italian 47Miller & Carter 46Dishoom